Liability limitation periods for hidden defects in consumer contracts

Marie De WitAdverit Zeist, Netherlands

This article discusses a ruling by the Amsterdam Court of Appeal of 17 December 2024 concerning liability expiry periods for hidden defects under the AVA 2013 general terms and conditions used in Dutch construction contracts. The court found these expiry periods unreasonably onerous and unfair towards consumers, and therefore unenforceable against them. The piece explains the underlying dispute involving a homeowner and contractor, and contrasts the AVA 2013 expiry regime with statutory limitation periods under the Civil Code. It also considers the wider implications for the Dutch construction industry, since similar expiry clauses appear in most standard construction terms.

Related practice areas

Construction law Real estate law

Other insights from this firm

View all legal insightsView all
M&A specialist Jan Willem Reesink joins Clairfort's Company Law and M&A team Corporate law This announcement reports that Jan Willem Reesink joined Clairfort on 1 May 2025 as a partner and department head in the Company Law and M&A team. It outlines his prior experience as a partner at Banning and nine years as an M&A lawyer at Van Doorne in Amsterdam. The piece describes his practice areas, including mergers and acquisitions, corporate governance, private equity, joint ventures and shareholder agreements. It notes that his clients include Dutch and foreign companies across various sectors. Clairfort IP team again in World Trademark Review 1000 – The World's Leading Trademark Professionals Intellectual property This article announces that Clairfort's IP team received two silver and two bronze rankings in the 2026 World Trademark Review 1000 list. It highlights recognition of the firm's trademark expertise on an international stage. The piece situates this achievement within the firm's ongoing investment in its Intellectual Property, IT & Privacy practice. It underscores the firm's continued visibility among leading trademark professionals worldwide.
Publication MARQUES: CJEU rules on copyright protection for works of applied art in Mio and Konektra cases Intellectual property This article reports on the 4 December 2025 ruling of the Court of Justice of the European Union in the joined Mio and Konektra cases. The decision addresses the threshold for copyright protection of works of applied art, an area historically marked by fragmented national approaches. It clarifies how originality is assessed for functional/design objects across the EU. The piece situates the judgment's implications for designers and manufacturers seeking copyright protection alongside or instead of design rights. Can you monopolize a colour? On colours and their protection under trademark law. Intellectual property This article examines the legal proceedings initiated by 7-Eleven against Nike over alleged trademark infringement relating to colour use. It explores the broader question of whether and how a colour can be monopolised as a trademark. The piece discusses the criteria courts apply to assess distinctiveness of colour marks and the tension between protecting brand identity and preserving fair competition. It situates the dispute within existing EU and Benelux trademark case law on colour marks.
Case report for MARQUES: Dutch court rules that Birkenstock sandals are protected by copyright Intellectual property This case report covers proceedings between Birkenstock and retail chain Scapino, in which Birkenstock claimed copyright protection for several of its iconic sandal models. The Dutch court's ruling addresses when a product design can meet the originality threshold required for copyright protection. The report discusses the reasoning behind extending copyright to footwear designs traditionally protected mainly by design rights. It highlights implications for brand owners seeking broader IP protection for product shapes. Clairfort welcomes Bonne Mulder to its Property & Construction team Construction lawCivil law Clairfort's Property & Construction team grew to nine specialists with the addition of Bonne Mulder. Mulder trained at a law firm in Amsterdam specialising in litigation and previously worked at a large accountancy firm before entering the legal profession.

Learn more about Adverit Zeist

This article was contributed by Adverit Zeist. Visit their website to learn more or discuss your situation with their legal team.

Visit local website (opens in a new tab)